The Final Dialogue Socrates speaks: Does God require an orator to speak for Him? A Daniel Webster to cajole, extol, and persuade The hearts and minds of fallen men? Or a comely maiden with eyes brown like almonds To feed Him, clothe Him, attend to His every need, Lest He wilt when He meets the crowd? I ask you, O Euthyphro, these facts to now explicate, To make my queries’ answers plainly and generally known. For when you say these things of love, hope, piety, That ‘tis but service to God, a meeting of His needs— These thoughts make just cause for death. O dearest friend, turn your most learned mind to think Of those proud, silvery-tongued rogues who dwelt of old And a sign of God demanded; Like petulant schoolchildren, their Maker them all consumed. I ask you, as a boon, to recall these tales from yore! For what need, joy, or good can He hope to derive? From beings born imperfect with impious hearts When He is the First Cause – perfect? Truly I ask you, does God need a— Euthyphro makes his response: O my dear, dear Socrates, that hemlock I fear Has gone to your head far more speedily Than we your jurors originally thought. Can you still not see the light though it Stares you cleanly in your face? To conceive This grand thought was no difficult matter, Not in the least to the meek who observe The ancient rituals, and remember Lessons learned at the breast of their nursemaids. It is as I have been taught, and it is As I have taught it to my poor brothers. A sinful lot is what you say we are, And from me, you shall not hear a dispute. Still we have our reasons still full intact, And with but an effort them we can use To attain the very celestial heights Where one day we shall be as the gods are. You, if I remember it correctly, Argued so when you quoted the dogma Of the divided line and the black cave. You are wise. It makes my heart very sad To think you die a sinful reprobate. That God needs the assistance of our race— Can truly there be any doubt at all? Socrates returns: “Does God require an orator to speak for Him?” I posed the question like the hour still was noonday When my wonderments you evaded. O my dear Euthyphro, how foolish we both are— I forgetting that I was poisoned, now deceased, As are you, my fellow phantom. Now as the sun once shined, I wholly can discern the Truth. I see His eyes, which cried many bitter tears for my sake; I see His hands, which bled my sad soul to purchase. And now I see you, O Euthyphro, so clearly; I see you now inside the flames. Poor, poor friend, you truly believed, while I doubted, And see my glorious company, and look at yours! I pity you, my poor brother. For you had a silvery tongue, soul, and brains, but not the Truth; How strong your faith was! Alas, in naught it was confided. Euthyphro, as the demons engulf him: Preposterous! Preposterous! You lie! You lie! You cheat! You dotardly fool! I go where you longed to go! I go to where I should, to the heaven of my soul! I’ll see you burn in hell, and relish it! You pest! You gad-fly! You empty-minded gad-fly! BURN! BURN! BURN! *** Opinions? |